Frequently Asked Questions For Researchers
Leadership
-
The BEACONS Genetic Condition Working Group is responsible for the curation and ongoing revision of this list of genetic conditions. The group is co-chaired by Nina Gold, MD, MS, and Britt Johnson, PhD, and is supported by program managers Stephanie Coury, MS, CGC and Harini Somanchi, BSPH. Additional members include Amber Begtrup, PhD, Steven Brenner, PhD, Dalia Kasperaviciute, PhD, Thomas Minten, PhD, Katie Langley, MS, CGC, Heidi Rehm, PhD, and Rebekah Zimmerman, PhD.
The Working Group incorporates input from a broad range of stakeholders, including leadership at the National Institutes of Health, the BEACONS Steering Committee and Community Advisory Board, rare disease advocacy organizations, clinical and research experts across multiple specialties, and individuals living with genetic conditions and their family members.
Inclusion Criteria for Genetic Conditions
-
Early identification of these genetic conditions is intended to enable interventions that substantially improve symptoms of the condition when initiated in the first year of life.
Inclusion criteria were derived from the International Consortium on Newborn Sequencing (ICoNS) consensus recommendations and adapted for a public health screening context.
Genetic conditions screened in BEACONS meet all of the following criteria:
An established gene–disease relationship associated with a condition affecting health or development.
Actionability within the first year of life, defined as a clinically approved treatment ora published surveillance guideline that can be initiated before age 1 and is expected to substantially improve health or development.
Availability of non-genetic confirmatory evidence, such as a laboratory biomarker, imaging finding, physical sign, or diagnostic criterion that can support diagnosis, or an available surveillance method that is considered to be low risk and potentially high benefit.
Technical feasibility, meaning reliable detection of likely pathogenic and pathogenic variants using short-read whole genome sequencing.
-
The goal of BEACONS is to find genetic conditions early, so that care can begin in the first year of life, when it can make the biggest difference for a child’s health.
A genetic condition is included if it meets all of the following criteria:
The condition affects a child’s health or development.
There is a treatment or medical monitoring plan that can start before age 1 and is expected to meaningfully improve health or prevent serious complications.
There are other ways, beyond the genetic test itself, to help confirm the diagnosis or guide care, such as blood tests, imaging, physical findings, or safe monitoring strategies.
The condition can be reliably detected using the type of genome sequencing used in BEACONS.
-
A condition was considered actionable if early identification enables:
A clinically available treatment that meaningfully alters medical management or outcomes
Avoidance of harmful interventions (e.g., ionizing radiation, live vaccines)
A surveillance strategy targeting a specific disease sequela within the first year of life, with favorable risk–benefit balance
The following examples, in isolation, were not considered to be sufficiently actionable:
Avoidance of a diagnostic odyssey
Access to clinical trials or experimental therapies
Initiation of supportive services, such as physical therapy or speech therapy
Personal, psychosocial, family, or economic utility
Reproductive decision-making
Information relevant only to parental medical care
-
Consistent with the consensus recommendations from the International Consortium on Newborn Sequencing (ICoNS), both relatively common conditions (e.g., G6PD deficiency) and ultra-rare disorders were included. Prevalence alone was not a determining factor.
-
We did not specifically consider disease penetrance (i.e., the likelihood that someone with a disease causing variant or variants will show the associated symptoms of the condition) when selecting genes and conditions for inclusion in this list of conditions. We acknowledge that the variable penetrance and expressivity of many conditions on the list may result in identification of asymptomatic infants. However, this decision reflects both:
Data on penetrance in the general population are unavailable
The ethical position that families may reasonably choose to pursue non-molecular confirmatory testing or low-risk surveillance interventions even when penetrance is uncertain
We did exclude genes for which reported penetrance was so low that the gene–disease relationship was uncertain (e.g., DUOX2). Additionally, variants associated with mild, minimally penetrant, or adult-onset phenotypes will be excluded from reporting.
-
Yes.
Many genes on the list are associated with conditions that can present at different ages and with a wide range of symptom severity. We included conditions for which a severe infantile form is known, even if the onset may occur in early childhood or adolescence. For genes with both infant-onset autosomal recessive and adult-onset autosomal dominant conditions, only biallelic variants will be reported.
Consistent with traditional newborn screening, we also included conditions that may present in the first days of life, recognizing that age of onset is often variable and that genetic information can guide treatment decisions in the first weeks or months of life even when the first symptoms present immediately after birth.
Development of Condition List
-
The first version of the list of genetic conditions included in BEACONS was constructed from three published sources:
Conditions that are actionable in the first week of life
Conditions that are currently screened on the Recommended Uniform Screening Panel
Conditions identified from prior genomic NBS studies and expert surveys that are actionable within the first year of life
The second version of the list incorporated:
Expert review from 57 clinicians, researchers, and laboratorians
Input from multiple rare disease advocacy organizations
An assessment of the genetic conditions included in the Genomics England Generation and GUARDIAN studies
Addition of congenital hearing loss and congenital heart disease
Removal of conditions that were found not to meet clinical or technical criteria
Feedback from the BEACONS Community Advisory Board
The third version of the list incorporated:
Feedback from state public health laboratories
Additional input from rare disease advocacy organizations
Removal of additional conditions that were found not to meet clinical or technical criteria
The final version of the list incorporated:
Final review from leadership at the National Institutes of Health
-
This list of genetic conditions is not comprehensive. We acknowledge that some conditions meeting BEACONS inclusion criteria may have been inadvertently excluded. We invite feedback at this link, which we will review as the study continues.
Variant Reporting and Reanalysis
-
No.
Optional condition selection was not implemented due to concerns about analytic complexity, consent burden, and resource requirements.
-
All likely pathogenic and pathogenic variants present in a dosage sufficient to cause disease (e.g., two variants in a gene associated with autosomal recessive inheritance) will be reported. Variants of uncertain significance will not be reported.
-
Only infants will be sequenced in BEACONS, initially. If two potentially autosomal recessive variants in the same gene are detected, in some cases, bioinformatic tools may allow for the phase of variants to be inferred. Additionally, with parent(s) consent and sample submission, BEACONS can perform testing of parental samples to establish if the two variants identified in the baby are in cis or trans.
-
Genomic data may be reanalyzed if a participant has a positive traditional newborn screen or clinical signs in the first year of life suggest a genetic condition.
Organization of the List
-
Conditions are grouped into 13 disease categories, including: inherited metabolic disorders, inborn errors of immunity, cardiac, neurologic, endocrine, renal, pulmonary, ophthalmologic, gastrointestinal, hematologic disorders, dermatologic, hearing loss, and hereditary cancer predisposition syndromes. Conditions are also categorized by whether or not they are a core condition on the RUSP.
-
Each entry includes:
Gene symbol
Relevant OMIM phenotype
Inheritance pattern and reporting strategy
Description of condition
Rationale for detection in infancy
Key diagnostic features and biomarkers
Treatments or surveillance approaches
Variant-level reporting notes when applicable
Supporting citations
Future Directions
-
The list of conditions screened in the BEACONS study will be reviewed and revised in approximately one year. We invite feedback here, which we will review as the study continues.